Skip navigation
January 04, 2022

When pride comes before the fall: the problem of anthropocentric hubris

My name is Haydn Washington. I have been a wilderness conservationist since 1974 when I became  a leader in the campaign to protect Wollemi. I am an environmental scientist and writer  and am currently an adjunct lecturer at UNSW, Sydney.   

During much of my academic career I have explored the problems of anthropocentrism – that is, humanity’s excessive hubris, that is pride and arrogance when interacting with the rest of life. Recently I co-authored a paper with four other academics called ‘The trouble with anthropocentric hubris, with examples from conservation’, which summarises much of my thinking, research and writing about anthropocentrism over four decades. It is the most important paper I have written and is available free of charge here: https://www.mdpi.com/2673-7159/1/4/22

Most traditional, indigenous societies were not anthropocentric and instead observed a kinship ethics. For example, Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people describe kinship systems which encompass sophisticated relations to other humans and to Country.  

By contrast, anthropocentrism is a dominant characteristic of the culture of modern, industrial society, whereby human values and needs take priority above those of the natural world. According to this world view, nature is little more than a resource for mankind to exploit. As such, anthropocentrism is an affirmation of ‘human supremacy’ and a way of life that, I would argue, is fuelling the environmental crisis and accelerating species extinction.  It is certainly not an ecologically sustainable or practical way to live on Earth.

Some of the key troubles with anthropocentrism are:

  • Worldview and ethics: Non-human Nature is commonly seen as having no agency, rights or need to be respected.
  • Dualisms, valuation and values: Because they have culture, humans are often seen as separate from Nature. And the egoism in modern industrial society assumes that humans have greater intrinsic value than Nature.
  • Ownership: Anthropocentrism portrays humanity philosophically as ‘owners’ of Nature. Yet, several scholars argue that ownership of land is largely a Western idea, not an Indigenous one historically.
  • Impracticality: humanity has obligate dependence on Nature to survive. For all our vaunted intelligence, the food we eat, the water we drink, the air we breathe—all come to us from Nature, which also cycles the nutrients in our crops and provides all the other myriad gifts that society needs.
  • A psychology of fear and denial: Humanity has a serious problem—we deny a reality we do not like, as, for example, catastrophic climate change. We deny some things as they force us to ‘confront change’, or are just too painful, or make us afraid.

So, what is the alternative? I would say that it is time to for western society to adopt an ecocentric worldview and an ecological ethics. The last century has seen massive loss of habitat, populations and species. These phenomena have become so acute that some have argued that our current epoch is ‘the Anthropocene’, though a more correct term is the ‘era of ecocide’. If humanity is to have any hope of halting this disastrous trend, concepts of fairness and justice cannot continue to be limited purely to humanity, but must explicitly be foregrounded to extend to non-human Nature.  

 

 

 

 

Continue Reading

Read More

MJD - In memory of Myles Joseph Dunphy

August 08, 2022

the leather bootsare cracked and dryhobnails rusting outyet I half expectedyou to arrive and pull them onfor day dawnedcrisp, clear, autumnalthe dusty aircleared by rain in powerful flightswans passed overheada pulsing arrowheadcleaving the sky just the kind of dayyou enjoyed striding bareleggedthrough coastal heathlandbrushing...

Read more

The Squirrel Glider - Protect the Wild Places This Species Relies On

July 27, 2022

Commonly mistaken for the Sugar Glider, the Squirrel Glider is the larger of the two species and grows to up to twice the size, with a head and body length of 20cm.  The Squirrel Glider is brown-gray in color with a dark stripe down...

Read more

Wilderness Australia Board Retreat - Building our 2022-2026 Strategic Plan

July 05, 2022

Wilderness Australia is an organisation with bold objects: the expansion, protection, and restoration of Australia’s wilderness areas and other landscapes of high environmental significance, for the purpose of sustaining the ecological processes on which all life depends.  To be successful in our efforts, we...

Read more

Join our community

Australian Foundation for Wilderness Limited
ACN 001 112 143
ABN 84 001 112 143
Advocating as 'Wilderness Australia'
Formerly The Colong Foundation for Wilderness Ltd
Registered Office 10/154 Elizabeth Street Sydney NSW 2000
Built by Code Nation using NationBuilder
Design by Think Creative Agency and Guy Threlfo